October 31, 2023

Is carbon offsetting the answer to climate change?

Explore the EU's efforts to combat greenwashing and the pivotal role of carbon offsetting.
Ora Learn is written by our team of experts with the mission of simplifying carbon investing for everyone. Start investing with Ora

As the European Union pioneers a transformative shift in consumer rights laws, the world watches closely. At the heart of this development is the fight against "greenwashing" - a phenomenon where companies exaggerate their environmentally friendly efforts to appear more eco-conscious than they are. However, as we examine these proposed changes, it's key to recognize the important role that carbon offsetting plays in achieving sustainability goals, even as we grapple with the complex question of what constitutes a "verified" offset.

The Greenwashing Challenge

Greenwashing for marketing purposes has often been more a frustration for environmental activists than a regulatory concern. While it irked those who sought genuine change from companies, it was, to some extent, considered a part of the game. However, the landscape has evolved. Since 2019, the rise of ESG (Environmental, Social, and Governance) investing has elevated the legal pitfalls of greenwashing. It's no longer just about clever marketing campaigns but potentially misleading investors. The European Union's proposal provides a much-needed regulatory framework to empower consumers and guide companies in substantiating their environmentally friendly claims.

The proposed legislation, which seeks to modify the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive and the Consumer Rights Directive, is specifically designed to tackle greenwashing. These changes align with the environmental goals of the EU's Green Deal and aim to prevent companies from exaggerating their environmental initiatives. They provide consumers with recourse when they fall victim to greenwashing, offering a path to hold companies accountable.

However, as we explore the world of sustainability and environmental responsibility, we must address the role of carbon offsetting in this equation. In the proposal, unfair claims based on greenhouse gas emissions offsetting are included in the list of banned commercial practices, preventing traders from making unverified assertions of a product's neutral, reduced, or improved environmental impact. The proposal's intent is commendable, but it should not overshadow the importance of practical solutions to mitigate emissions. Many businesses, despite their best efforts, still struggle to eliminate emissions completely from their supply chains. This is where carbon offsetting becomes a valuable tool.

The Role of Carbon Offsetting

Carbon offsetting is the practice of compensating for one's carbon emissions by investing in projects that remove or avoid an equivalent amount of greenhouse gasses elsewhere. These projects could include reforestation efforts, renewable energy initiatives, or methane capture from landfills. In essence, carbon offsetting allows companies to balance out their emissions by supporting activities that contribute to a reduction in greenhouse gasses.

While the EU's proposal correctly emphasizes the need for verified offsets, the question that looms large is, "What defines a 'verified' offset?". Verification must be rigorous and transparent, ensuring that the offsets genuinely contribute to emissions reductions. However, this should not hinder the ability of companies to access and utilize carbon offsetting as a practical tool in their sustainability journey.

The intrinsic value of carbon offsetting lies in its ability to address emissions that companies can't completely eliminate from their supply chain. This is a realistic and pragmatic approach to tackling climate change. To set the bar too high with overly restrictive definitions of "verified" offsets may limit the use of this valuable tool. Striking the right balance between ensuring offset quality and not stifling its accessibility is a challenge that regulators worldwide must address.

There's one company that stands out in effectively striking this balance and incorporating carbon credits into its comprehensive net-zero strategy: tech giant, Apple. Apple has embarked on an ambitious journey towards carbon neutrality, and purchasing carbon credits plays a pivotal role in achieving this goal.

Embracing Carbon Offsetting

What makes Apple's approach particularly noteworthy is its active participation in carbon offsetting projects. In their 2022 Environmental Progress report, the company outlines its commitment to achieving carbon neutrality across its entire value chain by 2030. They have already taken significant steps, such as using 100% renewable electricity and energy efficiency measures to reduce corporate emissions. However, some emissions, like those from natural gas use and business air travel, remain challenging to eliminate.

In response to these challenges, Apple has forged partnerships with Conservation International and will invest up to $200 million in a range of projects designed to generate carbon credits. These projects align with international standards developed by organizations like the Verified Carbon Standard (VCS), the Climate, Community & Biodiversity Standard (CCBS), and the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC), ensuring that they meet the highest standards of measurement and environmental integrity. Notable projects include:

  • The "Mangrove Forest Protection and Restoration Project" in Colombia: This project aims to protect and restore a 27,000-acre mangrove forest, which is expected to sequester 1 million metric tons of CO2 over its lifetime.
  • The "Chyulu Hills Restoration Project" in Kenya: Apple retired 167,000 metric tons of carbon credits from this project to maintain carbon neutrality for corporate emissions in fiscal year 2021. It focuses on the restoration of degraded savannas in the Chyulu Hills region.
  • A "Micro-Forestry" initiative partnering with marginalized farmers to earn a living through sustainable tree farming.

The Significance of Verified Offsets

Apple's dedication to sustainability extends to the quality of the carbon offset projects it supports. While the European Union and global organizations work to define "verified" offsets, Apple ensures that the offsets it invests in meet stringent criteria for environmental integrity. The company's commitment to transparency and high standards means that the projects it supports have undergone rigorous evaluation and adhere to stringent environmental criteria. These projects also aim to enhance the livelihoods of local communities while safeguarding lands with high conservation values.

Apple's participation in the Voluntary Carbon Market highlights the vital role these credits play in achieving carbon neutrality. As a forward-thinking tech giant, Apple acknowledges that some emissions are challenging to eliminate completely, and this predicament is not unique to them. Many companies across industries face similar emissions challenges and will need to buy carbon credits to meet their net-zero goals. Carbon credits provide a practical solution for bridging the emissions gap while simultaneously supporting critical environmental initiatives. By setting an example in their commitment to carbon credits, Apple underscores the importance for other companies to adopt similar strategies. In doing so, businesses can actively address their environmental impact, promote sustainability, and contribute to global efforts to combat climate change.

The Potential of Carbon Offset Solutions

As the EU moves forward with its proposed legislation to combat greenwashing, it's essential to remember that carbon offsetting is not the enemy. It's a valuable ally in the pursuit of sustainability goals. The focus should be on defining "verified" offsets in a manner that ensures environmental integrity while not creating unnecessary barriers for businesses. Striking this balance will be key to the success of future sustainability initiatives.

Get started

Want to invest
before the rest?

Join the waitlist and be among the first to invest in carbon credits

Want to Invest before the rest?

Join the waitlist and be among the first to invest in carbon credits